Thank you for watching! In the face of unrelenting disinformation and authoritarian actions, clear truth-telling and independent media are a necessity. If you value pro-democracy journalism, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber to my newsletter. Paid subscribers empower this work and gain access to exclusive benefits. Your support makes a difference.
Kristi Noem is out as Secretary of Homeland Security. And yes, Don Lemon and I took a moment to appreciate the karma. But this conversation was bigger than her.
In our latest weekly Two Brothers Talking Substack Live, we got right to the breaking news. Trump posted on Truth Social, firing Noem, and within minutes, she was on a stage in Nashville, taking questions from law enforcement as if nothing happened. It was, as I put it, genuinely embarrassing and hilarious.
Whether she knew in that moment or not, the image said everything: a person who sold her soul to Trumpism, standing in front of a crowd that was still calling her Madam Secretary while Trump was already posting about her replacement.
Don talked about karma coming home to roost, and we joked about Rep. Jared Moskowitz’s “Justice for Cricket” button. But underneath the humor, Don and I made an argument that I think matters more than the firing itself: this is not full accountability. This is Trump finding a fall guy. Or in this case, a fall gal.
The real story is not that Noem is gone. It is what her exit is designed to do, who comes next, and the fact that after this firing, Stephen Miller and Donald Trump are still in the building.
You can watch our full conversation above and read key takeaways below.
Good Riddance. Now Let’s Be Clear About Why She’s Actually Gone.
Don and I both felt the satisfaction of this moment. But we were equally clear that satisfaction has limits. Noem was not fired for the cruelty. She was fired for making Trump look bad on television.
Don laid out the full karma ledger: the people detained on the streets, the American citizens held without cause, the homes broken into with battering rams, the families racially profiled, the people deported to countries they had never lived in. Renee Good and Alex Pretti, killed by federal agents in Minneapolis. That is what Noem oversaw. That should have been the reason she was fired. It was not.
I pointed out what actually triggered the firing: her Senate testimony this week, where she claimed Trump personally approved a $220 million taxpayer-funded ad campaign to promote self-deportation. He said he didn’t approve it. That is the moment Trump decided she had to go. Not the ICE abuses. Not the deaths. The moment she made him look bad in a hearing.
Don made the perjury point directly: if she testified that Trump approved the ad and he says he didn’t, is Trump claiming she committed perjury? And the pardon question hanging over all of it is genuinely interesting. If Trump were to pardon her for perjury, does that mean he’s admitting she told the truth?
I connected the ad contract itself to the self-dealing pattern: the people who received the contract had ties to Noem and Noem’s spokesperson. She was not just incompetent. She was grifting. And Trump’s rule, as I put it, is simple: only he gets to grift.
Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) dismantled her in that hearing. Don described it perfectly: she looked like a schoolgirl being called to the principal’s office. When Tillis brought up Cricket, the puppy she killed and wrote about in her memoir as a demonstration of toughness, she looked down. A Republican senator used the killing of a dog as an example of her poor judgment. He was right.
Don’t Let Republicans Use This As Cover
This is the political play I flagged, and I want our audience to understand it before it happens.
Republicans are already going to try to use this firing as a reset narrative. The argument will be: Trump course-corrected, Noem went too far, and Trump handled it. I said it plainly: do not let that land. Stephen Miller designed the immigration enforcement agenda. Donald Trump signed off on all of it. Noem was the face, not the architect.
The abuses at ICE and DHS did not begin and end with Kristi Noem. The family separations, the wrongful detentions, the deaths in Minneapolis, the deportations to torture chambers, as I described what happened in El Salvador, all of it flows from the top. Firing the face does not absolve the people who built the machine.
Don made the broader point about accountability and the American people’s trust. Trump was elected. He appointed her. In a secondhand way, she was working for all of us. She violated that trust from day one. A personnel change is not justice for the people whose lives were upended by what she oversaw.
Markwayne Mullin Is Not an Upgrade
Trump named Republican Senator Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma as Noem’s replacement, effective March 31. We talked about what that actually means.
Mullin’s first public comments told us everything we needed to know. This week, he said “we’re at war” and then when pressed said “no, we’re not at war, the president hasn’t declared war.” When told he had just said we were at war, he said it was a “misspoke.” I joked that was the moment he got the job. Trump is watching that and thinking, " You’ll fit right in.
Don played a clip of Mullin defending the administration’s use of “lethality at home and abroad.” Don’s take: he is as dumb as a box of rocks, and my apologies to rocks. My take: the keyword was “at home.” We already have too much of that. We do not need a DHS secretary promising more of it.
I pointed out that Mullin has been defending everything this administration does with total loyalty and zero critical thinking. That is exactly what got Noem this far. The most important job qualification in Trump’s cabinet is not competence. It is loyalty. Mullin has demonstrated he can do that.
Don flagged Pam Bondi and Pete Hegseth as the next dominoes to watch. His theory: if the Noem firing gets Trump a polling bump, he will look at who else is making him look bad and start cleaning house ahead of the midterms. I think he is right. Hegseth is a disaster communicator on the Iran war. Bondi fumbled the Epstein files hearing. Both of them have been building a public record of failure that Trump may eventually decide is more liability than asset.
Accountability Season Is Here
Don introduced the karma framework at the top, and we kept coming back to it. By the end, I think we landed somewhere real.
Don broke the news live during our conversation: Lindsey Halligan, the former US attorney in the Eastern District of Virginia who brought criminal charges against Trump’s political enemies over the objections of career prosecutors, is now under investigation by Florida’s Bar Association. The investigation could lead to disbarment, though the process is lengthy.
I made the point that I think is the most important one: the people around Trump think they can latch onto him and inherit his invulnerability. They cannot. Trump has survived everything. They will not. He cannot pardon Halligan out of a disbarment proceeding. He threw Noem under the bus the moment she became inconvenient. This is a one-way loyalty arrangement, and his former allies keep learning that the hard way.
Don put it plainly at the end: the people who were detained, profiled, shipped to foreign countries, had their doors broken down, the people who were killed — they deserve real accountability, not a personnel shuffle. Laughing at Noem getting fired is fine. Mistaking it for justice is not.
Bottom Line
Kristi Noem is gone, and the karma is real. Don and I are not going to pretend otherwise. She oversaw cruelty, she self-dealt with taxpayer money, she defamed Renee Good and Alex Pretti after their deaths, and she killed a puppy and wrote about it like it was a character reference. Good riddance.
But the machine she ran is still running. Stephen Miller is still there. Donald Trump is still there. Markwayne Mullin is on his way. And the tell is always the same with this administration: the things that should have gotten her fired, the deaths, the wrongful detentions, the deportations to torture chambers, none of that moved Trump. What moved Trump was a bad TV moment. That is the standard. That is who is running the country.
Accountability season is here, and it is just getting started. But real accountability does not end with Kristi Noem being sent to a made-up envoy role. It ends when the people who built this agenda face the same consequences the rest of us would.
If this conversation mattered to you, become a paid subscriber to Ahmed Baba News and subscribe to Don Lemon on Substack. Independent journalism only survives when you back the people doing it.
