Thank you for watching! In the face of unrelenting disinformation and authoritarian actions, clear truth-telling and independent media are a necessity. If you value pro-democracy journalism, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber to my newsletter. Paid subscribers empower this work and gain access to exclusive benefits. Your support makes a difference.
Scott Pelley walked into an all-hands meeting with Bari Weiss’s hand-picked 60 Minutes executive producer, Nick Bilton, and spoke truth to power. He was fired for speaking that truth. That is the only way to describe what happened at CBS.
I couldn’t think of a better person to talk about this with than Don Lemon. When I sat down for our latest Substack Live conversation, what emerged was more than media commentary. It was a firsthand account from someone who has been in similar rooms, heard similar lies, and lived through a similar playbook, now being run at CBS News, when Chris Licht took over CNN, and led to Don’s ousting.
Don called Pelley a hero. And rightfully so. Pelley has effectively acted as a whistleblower. In that now-famous all-hands meeting, Pelley reportedly said that Bari Weiss is “murdering 60 Minutes. She does not love this place. She was brought in to kill it, and she’s been doing exactly that.”
After he was fired, he released a statement, accusing CBS’s new management, the Trump-allied Ellisons and their chosen Editor-in-Chief Bari Weiss, of asking him to “inject falsehoods and bias into a politically sensitive story.” He said politicians were being “invited to choose their own correspondents for interviews.” He said the Ellisons were trying to curry favor with the Trump Administration.
This is CBS News. The network of Walter Cronkite. And Don’s response when he watched it unfold was not surprise. It was recognition of a familiar playbook.
This isn’t just a story about executives making bad business decisions. This is about the erosion of America’s democratic infrastructure, our information ecosystem. The media is called the Fourth Estate for a reason.
Journalism is supposed to function as democracy’s immune system. And what is happening at CBS, what happened at CNN under Chris Licht and could happen again if the Ellisons complete their takeover of the network, and what is happening across the American media landscape as corporate owners seek favor with the White House, is an autoimmune disease. The body is attacking itself in order to seek favor with a regime hell-bent on eroding the foundations of democracy that uphold the Fourth Estate.
Don and I spent ten sharp minutes on exactly that.
You can watch our full conversation above and read key takeaways below. And, as always, thank you for supporting independent media.
Scott Pelley Is A Hero & The Attack On The Truth That Led To His Ousting Should Be A Five Alarm Fire
Don did not mince words. Neither did I. What Pelley did was an act of courage that should be a wake-up call for everyone in this industry and everyone who depends on it.
Don called it immediately: this should be a five-alarm fire, a break-the-glass moment, and he does not see that response from enough people. He said watching what these companies are doing to appease the Trump administration should be frightening to everyone in the business. The media world is small. People know each other. And when a CBS News anchor says he was instructed to inject falsehoods into a story, the correct response should be industry-wide alarm.
Don knew the script before it played out because he lived it. As Pelley was sharing his account of those management meetings, Don said he was reading it thinking: I know they are going to lie about the last meeting. I know they are going to say he was not cooperative. I know how this goes because I have been in those rooms. That is not analysis. That is testimony. And it matters because it confirms that what happened to Pelley is not an isolated incident at one broken company. It is a pattern.
Nicole Wallace told Don it was triggering for her too. When he appeared on MS NOW yesterday, she confided that watching what is happening at CBS is deeply unsettling for anyone who believes in journalism. Don noted she is not just a television host. She is a former White House communications director under a Republican president. When that person is alarmed by what is happening to the press, that is a signal worth paying attention to.
In a world of Bari Weisses, be a Scott Pelley. Don said it plainly, and it deserves to be repeated. Pelley did not just defend himself. He defended his colleagues. He defended 60 Minutes. He defended the principle that a news organization exists to inform the public, not to curry regulatory favor for a corporate owner trying to close a merger. That is what a journalist does. That is what the fourth estate is for.
This is not a story about executives making bad decisions. I made this point directly, and I want to be clear about it: what is happening at CBS is not a management story. It is not a business story. It is a story about the erosion of America’s democratic information infrastructure. Journalism is called the fourth estate for a reason. It is not just another for-profit pursuit. It exists to uphold public trust and to hold power accountable. When the owners of CBS decide that White House approval matters more than that function, they are not making a bad business decision. They are making a choice about what kind of country we live in.
The Access Game & What News Organizations Should Actually Do
Don pulled back the curtain on something the public rarely sees: the quiet negotiations over access that have been eroding editorial independence at news organizations long before the Ellisons arrived at CBS.
Politicians demanding to choose their interviewers is not new, and news organizations enabling it is the real problem. Don was clear that what Pelley described, politicians being invited to select their own correspondents, has been happening at other organizations for years, including CNN. Politicians learn they can make these demands because they have been accommodated before. The correct response, Don said, is to expose it publicly. Tell the audience: we offered this person an interview, they wanted to pick the correspondent, we do not do that here, so they are not coming on. That transparency would end the behavior immediately because no politician wants that story told about them.
The people getting the most access are usually the ones softballing the interviews. Don did not hedge on this. Some news organizations pull their punches because they want access, and the way you keep access is by not making powerful people uncomfortable. The result is that the journalists with the most face time with power are often the ones doing the least to hold it accountable. That is a transaction. And it is why independent journalists and those willing to lose access by doing their jobs are more valuable to the public than ever.
Short-term access always destroys long-term credibility. I made this case directly: every time a news organization accommodates a demand from a politician or an administration to protect its access, it is making a trade it cannot win. The audience notices. Trust erodes. And then when you need that trust, when a real story breaks, and you need people to believe you, it is gone. What Scott Pelley did by going public is the opposite of that trade. He chose credibility over access, permanently. That should be the model for good journalism.
Advice To Journalists & What Is At Stake Amid Right-Wing Media Consolidation
Don’s advice to journalists watching this was direct, specific, and grounded in what he has personally lived through. And the picture he painted of where the Ellisons are taking CBS makes the stakes undeniable.
If someone gives you an illegal order, you do not have to carry it out. Don drew an explicit parallel to what Democratic leaders told military personnel: if you are given an order that requires you to compromise your journalistic integrity, do not comply, and document it. Go to HR. Put it in writing that you refused and explain why, that what was being asked of you violates company policy, journalistic standards, and potentially the law. Don said as long as you stand on that ground, you will be fine. But you have to start standing up to the corporations. You have to.
Courage is contagious, and Pelley may have just changed the temperature. Don echoed what Jim Acosta said on MS NOW with him: courage is contagious. Don said he hopes what Pelley did inspires other journalists to be more courageous, the same way what he did after CNN, and what Acosta did, encouraged others. Nicole Wallace told him she often finds herself following the editorial lead of independent journalists now rather than the other way around. This signals that the center of gravity in journalism may be shifting toward those willing to take more risks.
CBS Evening News is cratering, and 60 Minutes was the one thing that was growing. Don made the business case as clearly as the democratic one: CBS Evening News is suffering under the new regime. The Morning Show is suffering. The one program that was not suffering, that was actually growing its audience both in linear television and in digital, was 60 Minutes. The Ellisons took the one thing that was working and decided to break it. That is not a business decision. That is an ideological one. And it tells you everything you need to know about what they are actually trying to accomplish.
If the Ellisons get CNN, we will already know what happens because we are watching it happen at CBS. I raised this directly, and Don’s answer was unambiguous: look at CBS. That is your preview. The international reporting, the institutional credibility, the journalists who have spent careers building trust with sources around the world, all of it becomes a negotiating chip for corporate owners who need something from the White House. Journalism as a public service does not survive that transaction. And right now, the Ellisons are showing us exactly what they do when they own a newsroom.
Bottom Line
Scott Pelley stood up in the middle of an all-hands meeting and told the truth about what was being done to his newsroom. Don Lemon recognized every beat because he lived through the same script. The pattern is clear. Corporate owners seek right-wing audiences or need regulatory favors. The White House has demands. Journalists get told to inject falsehoods, accommodate right-wing pressure, and pull their punches. The ones who refuse get fired. The ones who go public become heroes. As Don said, in a world of Bari Weisses, be a Scott Pelley.
This is why Independent media is so important. If this conversation mattered to you, I hope you consider becoming a paid subscriber to Ahmed Baba News and also consider supporting Don Lemon. And if you’re already a paid subscriber, thank you! It truly means a lot. Independent media runs on the people who back it.
